Comments on: Doctor Who: Legends of a Time Lord – Episode 1 – Springheel Jack Part 1 http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/ A Web Audio Production Company Wed, 01 Feb 2012 07:40:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Nick Armstrong http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1295 Nick Armstrong Mon, 24 Aug 2009 23:12:00 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1295 I can't really be impartial, but... this is the first Doctor Who iteration I like. Like any series, it's going to have a rough first episode - but I think Ryan and John have done a nice job setting up the premise for people who may not be straight-out Doctor Who fans. I'd much rather have a frontally-didactic first episode than something I'd get lost on. Like I said - not impartial, but, for a non-Doctor Who fan, I was impressed. -Nick Armstrong Writer, Star Trek: Dimensions I can’t really be impartial, but… this is the first Doctor Who iteration I like.

Like any series, it’s going to have a rough first episode – but I think Ryan and John have done a nice job setting up the premise for people who may not be straight-out Doctor Who fans. I’d much rather have a frontally-didactic first episode than something I’d get lost on.

Like I said – not impartial, but, for a non-Doctor Who fan, I was impressed.

-Nick Armstrong
Writer, Star Trek: Dimensions

]]> By: Nick Armstrong http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1692 Nick Armstrong Mon, 24 Aug 2009 23:12:00 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1692 I can't really be impartial, but... this is the first Doctor Who iteration I like. Like any series, it's going to have a rough first episode - but I think Ryan and John have done a nice job setting up the premise for people who may not be straight-out Doctor Who fans. I'd much rather have a frontally-didactic first episode than something I'd get lost on. Like I said - not impartial, but, for a non-Doctor Who fan, I was impressed. -Nick Armstrong Writer, Star Trek: Dimensions I can’t really be impartial, but… this is the first Doctor Who iteration I like.

Like any series, it’s going to have a rough first episode – but I think Ryan and John have done a nice job setting up the premise for people who may not be straight-out Doctor Who fans. I’d much rather have a frontally-didactic first episode than something I’d get lost on.

Like I said – not impartial, but, for a non-Doctor Who fan, I was impressed.

-Nick Armstrong
Writer, Star Trek: Dimensions

]]> By: Gareth Preston http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1294 Gareth Preston Mon, 24 Aug 2009 21:00:01 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1294 Springheel Jack is an interesting Victorian folk tale but so far this story has failed to catch light. The Doctor rabbits on to himself for ages. Characters talking to themselves is something I really try to avoid if possible in a radio script and I think I've failed if I have to have it occur. I would dropped the TARDIS scene and got the Doctor into the action faster. There's little sense of menace so far. All that's happened is that Doctor has been mistaken for someone else. WE know he's not the killer, and the police may arrest him but they won't really harm him. There's not enough conflict yet. David Maciver needs to put more colour into his voice. At the moment its all on one level and there's no energy. Similarly Sammy Rey's Emily doesn't seem to get too concerned about anything. Sorry but my mind kept wandering throughout this episode. It needs a lot more oomph, more speed, a sense that something is at stake affecting the people I am listening too, rather than general ripper chronology going on in the background. Springheel Jack is an interesting Victorian folk tale but so far this story has failed to catch light.
The Doctor rabbits on to himself for ages. Characters talking to themselves is something I really try to avoid if possible in a radio script and I think I’ve failed if I have to have it occur. I would dropped the TARDIS scene and got the Doctor into the action faster.
There’s little sense of menace so far. All that’s happened is that Doctor has been mistaken for someone else. WE know he’s not the killer, and the police may arrest him but they won’t really harm him. There’s not enough conflict yet.
David Maciver needs to put more colour into his voice. At the moment its all on one level and there’s no energy. Similarly Sammy Rey’s Emily doesn’t seem to get too concerned about anything.
Sorry but my mind kept wandering throughout this episode. It needs a lot more oomph, more speed, a sense that something is at stake affecting the people I am listening too, rather than general ripper chronology going on in the background.

]]> By: Gareth Preston http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1691 Gareth Preston Mon, 24 Aug 2009 21:00:00 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1691 Springheel Jack is an interesting Victorian folk tale but so far this story has failed to catch light. The Doctor rabbits on to himself for ages. Characters talking to themselves is something I really try to avoid if possible in a radio script and I think I've failed if I have to have it occur. I would dropped the TARDIS scene and got the Doctor into the action faster. There's little sense of menace so far. All that's happened is that Doctor has been mistaken for someone else. WE know he's not the killer, and the police may arrest him but they won't really harm him. There's not enough conflict yet. David Maciver needs to put more colour into his voice. At the moment its all on one level and there's no energy. Similarly Sammy Rey's Emily doesn't seem to get too concerned about anything. Sorry but my mind kept wandering throughout this episode. It needs a lot more oomph, more speed, a sense that something is at stake affecting the people I am listening too, rather than general ripper chronology going on in the background. Springheel Jack is an interesting Victorian folk tale but so far this story has failed to catch light.
The Doctor rabbits on to himself for ages. Characters talking to themselves is something I really try to avoid if possible in a radio script and I think I’ve failed if I have to have it occur. I would dropped the TARDIS scene and got the Doctor into the action faster.
There’s little sense of menace so far. All that’s happened is that Doctor has been mistaken for someone else. WE know he’s not the killer, and the police may arrest him but they won’t really harm him. There’s not enough conflict yet.
David Maciver needs to put more colour into his voice. At the moment its all on one level and there’s no energy. Similarly Sammy Rey’s Emily doesn’t seem to get too concerned about anything.
Sorry but my mind kept wandering throughout this episode. It needs a lot more oomph, more speed, a sense that something is at stake affecting the people I am listening too, rather than general ripper chronology going on in the background.

]]> By: Ryan Cassavaugh http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1228 Ryan Cassavaugh Thu, 20 Aug 2009 23:32:13 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1228 Excellent premiere episode everyone! I am very happy with how it turned out. Excited for Episode #2 Excellent premiere episode everyone! I am very happy with how it turned out. Excited for Episode #2

]]> By: Ryan Cassavaugh http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1690 Ryan Cassavaugh Thu, 20 Aug 2009 23:32:00 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1690 Excellent premiere episode everyone! I am very happy with how it turned out. Excited for Episode #2 Excellent premiere episode everyone! I am very happy with how it turned out. Excited for Episode #2

]]> By: Dam Productions, Giant Gnome & BrokenSea: New Episodes « BOTCHERBY’S http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1225 Dam Productions, Giant Gnome & BrokenSea: New Episodes « BOTCHERBY’S Thu, 20 Aug 2009 21:07:25 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1225 [...] Springheel Jack (part 1): http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1... [...] [...] Springheel Jack (part 1): http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1... [...]

]]> By: John Lingard http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1222 John Lingard Thu, 20 Aug 2009 16:42:27 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1222 Well worth the wait!! It's great to be working with such a talented team. J.L. (Policeman #1) Well worth the wait!! It’s great to be working with such a talented team.
J.L. (Policeman #1)

]]> By: John Lingard http://www.giantgnome.com/2009/08/doctor-who-legends-of-a-time-lord-episode-1-springheel-jack-part-1/comment-page-1/#comment-1689 John Lingard Thu, 20 Aug 2009 16:42:00 +0000 http://www.giantgnome.com/?p=521#comment-1689 Well worth the wait!! It's great to be working with such a talented team. J.L. (Policeman #1) Well worth the wait!! It’s great to be working with such a talented team.
J.L. (Policeman #1)

]]>